Why Islamorada?
Islamorada is actually a village of six islands stretching from Plantation Key to Lower Matecumbe Key. It's known worldwide as the sportfishing capital, home to legendary charter captains, world-record catches, and a fishing culture that runs deep.
While oceanfront estates command premium prices, the village has a range of affordable options that most people don't expect. Older condos near the Overseas Highway, canal-front homes in established neighborhoods, and properties on the bayside can be found under $500K. The key is working with an agent who knows where the value pockets are.
What You'll Find Here
Price Range
$275K - $750K
Property Types
Condos, townhomes, older single-family homes
Best For
Anglers, outdoor enthusiasts, vacation home buyers, nature lovers
Rental Potential
High. Islamorada draws tourists year-round for fishing, diving, and eco-tourism.
Schools
Islamorada is served by the Monroe County School District:
- Mae L. Nett School (PK-8) — the main school serving the Islamorada community.
- Coral Shores High School (9-12) — located in Tavernier, serving upper Keys students with strong programs.
Local Amenities & Lifestyle
Islamorada has a surprising number of amenities for a Keys village: the Rainforest Adventure Zoo, the Theater of the Sea, world-class restaurants like Islamorada Fish Company and Chef Michael's, breweries, art galleries, and numerous marinas. The Florida Keys Overseas Heritage Trail passes through, and the theater of the sea dolphin encounters are a family favorite. The annual Islamorada Bull & Grotto tournament is one of the most prestigious fishing events in the world.